In a highly anticipated legal battle, a judge will soon decide whether to dismiss a sexual crime case involving the Alexander brothers, Oren and Alon, and their friend Ohad Fisherman. This decision could have significant consequences for both the defendants and the accuser, as Miami-Dade Circuit Court Judge Lody Jean is set to rule on a motion to dismiss the case by June 30.
The Controversial Motion to Dismiss
The Alexander brothers and Fisherman are facing serious charges related to a 2016 sexual assault that allegedly took place at a Miami Beach apartment on New Year’s Eve. Fisherman, who is accused of pinning down the victim while Oren and Alon Alexander took turns raping her, has denied the charges. But recently, his defense team filed a motion to dismiss the case, arguing that vital evidence has either been lost, destroyed, or was never properly preserved by state prosecutors.
If you want, you can also read about Oren Alexander Sells Waterfront Sunset Islands Mansion for $52M.
This motion is rooted in claims that the state failed to secure potential electronic evidence following the December 2016 arrests. According to the defense, this evidence is now in the hands of federal prosecutors. They further argue that if federal authorities are unwilling to hand over this evidence, the charges should be dismissed entirely. The defense team has expressed concern that this oversight could jeopardize the fairness of the trial.
The Upcoming Trial and Allegations
The trial, which is currently scheduled for July 7, 2025, will primarily focus on the actions of Fisherman during the 2016 incident, as he is the only one of the three accused individuals who will be standing trial. Oren and Alon Alexander are not expected to face charges in this particular case, as they are currently detained in a Brooklyn, New York, federal detention center. They face a series of federal charges related to sexual crimes, including rape and sexual trafficking, and their release is unlikely in the near future.
Fisherman, a close friend of the Alexander brothers, has not been accused of direct penetration during the alleged attack. He has been released on bond and is not required to wear an ankle monitor as he prepares for trial.
A Disturbing Account of the Night in Question
The victim in this case has shared her harrowing account with authorities. She states that she went to Alon Alexander’s apartment after receiving an invitation, which included pictures of people enjoying a barbecue on the apartment’s patio. However, upon arriving, she found that the scene was eerily empty. As she sat on a footrest at the end of a bed, Fisherman allegedly held her shoulders down from behind while the twins, Oren and Alon, discussed who would assault her first.
According to the victim’s statement, despite repeatedly telling them “no,” the twins disrobed her and used condoms during the assault. She claims that they proceeded with their actions even after her refusal.
Broader Allegations Against the Alexander Brothers
The Alexander brothers have come under scrutiny not only for this incident but also for their alleged involvement in numerous other sexual assault cases. State and federal prosecutors claim that the brothers used their wealth and status to lure women to their Miami Beach and New York apartments, as well as on trips both across the country and abroad. These women, the prosecution argues, were often drugged before being sexually assaulted.
In fact, during a federal hearing in New York, a witness testified that over four dozen women have come forward with allegations against the brothers. These women are said to be credible, and many of them have shared chilling accounts of their own experiences.
The Brothers’ Background and Arrests
Oren and Tal Alexander, the twin brothers at the center of this case, have long been known as influential figures in the real estate industry. Their roles in securing some of the largest residential sales contracts in the United States have cemented their positions in the high-end real estate world. Alon, meanwhile, has maintained an executive role in the family’s security business, which also contributes to their high-profile status.
On December 11, 2023, the three brothers were arrested at their Miami Beach homes in a coordinated effort involving both local police and federal agents. Just a week later, Fisherman turned himself in after returning from his honeymoon in Japan.
Civil Lawsuits and Further Allegations
The criminal charges against the Alexander brothers are not the only legal battles they face. Over two dozen women from both New York and South Florida have filed civil lawsuits, accusing them of sexual assault and seeking damages. These additional cases further complicate the public image of the brothers, casting a long shadow over their professional and personal lives.
A Long Road Ahead
As the case moves forward, the decision made by Judge Lody Jean will be crucial in determining the next steps for all parties involved. While the motion to dismiss could significantly alter the trajectory of the trial, it’s clear that the impact of these allegations will continue to ripple through both the legal system and the broader public perception of the Alexander brothers and their associates.
The emotional toll on the victim, the ongoing criminal investigations, and the many civil lawsuits paint a picture of a case that is far from simple. As the trial date approaches, all eyes will be on the courtroom, awaiting Judge Jean’s ruling on whether the case will proceed or be dismissed, and the dramatic consequences that will follow.